Are the current French protests justified? It depends on which layer of the system you look at.

If you listen to the students and teachers on the streets, their complaints about underfunded schools sound completely reasonable:

  • Unreplaced missing teachers
  • Overcrowded classrooms (often 30+ students)
  • Run-down facilities

Yet, look at the macroeconomic numbers and you hit a massive paradox:

  • France spent €199.2 billion on education in 2025 (6.7% of GDP)—putting it well above international and OECD averages.
  • Average spending per pupil sits at around €11,140.

So where is all the money actually going?

The short answer: Pensions.

To understand why French public services feel starved despite sky-high funding, you have to look under the hood of their Pay-As-You-Go (PAYG) pension scheme:

  1. The Budget Drain: Around 32% of the Education Ministry’s total budget goes straight to paying pensions (approx. €28.5B out of ~€89B in the 2027 budget).
  2. The Subsidy Problem: For every €100 paid in a teacher’s basic salary, the state contributes an extra €82 (an 82.28% employer contribution rate in 2026) just to cover civil-service pensions.
  3. Demographic Collapse: In the civil service pension scheme, there are only 0.94 active contributors for every retiree. (For context, the private sector sits around 1.5 to 1.6, and healthy PAYG systems aim for 1.5–2.0+).

How did we get here?

PAYG systems—where current workers’ taxes pay current retirees’ pensions directly, rather than individuals saving into their own investment pots—were created across post-WWII Europe for understandable reasons.

After WWII, older generations had lost their savings. PAYG allowed governments to deliver immediate relief to impoverished retirees without waiting decades to accumulate individual pension pots. With a massive post-war baby boom (4–5 workers per retiree), the system looked completely sustainable.

The Structural Trap

The model was never built for today’s demographic reality of low birth rates and longer lifespans. Because French civil service pensions are final-salary-based and relatively generous (up to 75%!!), teachers actually enjoy well-above-average retirement security.

However, because the scheme now has more retirees than active workers (0.94 ratio), the state must divert a huge share of current education funding just to pay former employees, leaving classrooms under-resourced today.

The verdict?

The students and teachers on the ground do have legitimate points about their daily conditions. But dumping more money into the current structure won’t fix it—the system itself is mathematically set up to fail.

It requires structural reform, but with current civil servants motivated to protect their retirement model, the political incentive is to keep kicking the can down the road.